Certified Public Accountant
Bookkeeping, Taxes & Business Consulting

But My S Corporation Lost Money… How Can I Not Deduct It?

Posted in by on
my S corporation lost money

You were a bit nervous about filing your tax return next year when your spouse received that 120,000-dollar performance bonus. Your spouse never fills out Form W-4 correctly, and is a chronic under-withholder. You ran into the office to calculate how much you’ve made so far this year, and to project where you will land on December 31.

While trying to remember several transactions that don’t ring a bell, you suddenly realize that the two pieces of equipment you purchased several months back, for which the combined price came to $200,000, were purchased and put into service in January of the current year, rather than November of the prior year, as you had seemed to remember. You quickly ask ChatGPT, and are overjoyed to realize that both pieces of equipment should qualify for Section 179. You may deduct the full amount of each one in the current year, which will result in a business loss of at least $170,000.

You’re going to clear this with your accountant first, as there have been a number of times he did not concur with your DIY findings. However, you feel like the situation has promise, and for the first time since last Friday you’re breathing a little easier. The next couple months leading up to your meeting with your accountant are good ones, as you figure that instead of an extra $40,000 in taxable income, you’re looking at $50,000 less in taxable income than what you would normally have.

You meet with your accountant, who confirms that both pieces of your equipment may be fully expensed in the filing year, and tells you he’ll look things over and get back to you soon. A few days later, you get a call with the unwelcome news that you owe $30,000.

But how can this be, you ask. What about $200,000 in equipment deductions? And then, your accountant explains that you have no shareholder basis to deduct a loss. What on earth has happened?

When an S corporation begins, and the shareholder, who, for simplicity’s sake, is a sole shareholder, opens a bank account with, say, $1,000, he has established basis for himself in the S corporation. Any corporate earnings increase basis, and any money taken out of the company by the shareholder, or any losses, decrease basis, and the shareholder may deduct those losses as long as his basis does not go below zero.

When these rules are applied to your financed equipment purchases, your scenario works out as follows. You have shareholder basis of $30,000 before applying the current-year loss. Your S corporation loss was $170,000. Of that $170,000, you may take a deduction to the extent of your basis, which is $30,000. The remaining $140,000 loss is not lost to you forever, but it is suspended, not benefiting you at all in the year in question.

Debt owed by the corporation to a third party does not give the shareholder basis. Debt directly to a shareholder may give that shareholder basis, but that’s a discussion beyond the scope of this article. Essentially, because the equipment was both financed and fully expensed in the year of purchase, all that results is a nice suspended loss that may bring you joy in a future year.

Your accountant is still all for taking Section 179, as projections suggest the next year should be a strong year for company earnings, with all necessary equipment in place, high demand for your services, and no additional anticipated capital outlay. That way, in the following year, the basis limitation would allow you to deduct the entire $140,000 suspended loss.

The rules regarding shareholder basis tend to be some of the less-intuitive in S corporation taxation. Your corporation truly had a deduction, and a loss because of that deduction, but you’ll get no mileage out of it on the tax return in which the deduction arose. A loss and the ability to deduct it are two different things.

This is not a situation that makes you happy, but your accountant is correct, and there is always next year! Sometimes, that’s the best we can do.

By Appointment Only:

Request An Appointment

Need Help?

Request a Free Consultation

Fill out Form below to email Gary for a free consultation.

©2014-2026 Gary Boyd, C.P.A., P.C | Accounting Services in Las Vegas and Henderson, NV Areas | BoydCPA.com
1540 W. Warm Springs Road, Suite 100, Henderson, NV 89014 | Phone: (702) 321-8804

Website Design by studio1c